Saturday, November 12, 2011

Cookbook Reviews


What it is: A three book collection that puts Alton Brown’s cooking show into book form.
Why I love it: These books are wonderfully informative. 60% food science, 30% recipes, and 10% miscellaneous trivia. Let me give an example. Sure the chapter on chocolate chip cookies includes Alton’s idea of the perfect recipe but even better, it includes a chart of standard cookie ingredients and how they affect the end product (like how the white to brown sugar ratio affects the crispy/chewy factor).
What I don’t love: The books are organized the way the show was. Meaning seasons = chapters and sub-chapters = episodes. It is fun but I often find myself flipping through the indexes of all three books before I can find the specific information I need. My dream book would reorganize this set into a food encyclopedia organized by subject instead of by episode.

 (Mostly just available from Disney's resorts etc but you can find it second hand online)
What it is: A collection of recipes from Disney’s resort and cruise line restaurants. I picked this up on my honeymoon to Disney World Orlando.
Why I love it: Personally, it’s a lovely memory from our honeymoon; I love that I can cook a meal we enjoyed on our honeymoon to celebrate an anniversary. In general, Disney food is pretty darn good!
The organization is nicely done. Each chapter includes recipes from different parks and then arranges them from drinks/breakfasts/appetizers to main dishes/sides to desserts. Each recipe includes a note on which restaurant it is featured in and, in some cases, cooking tips, drink pairings, and/or history of the dish’s origins.
What I don’t love: A lot of these recipes are really pricey (pork tenderloin, crab cakes, crème brulée…). I usually only use it when I can afford to splurge a little. It is not a college student-on a budget-weeknight kind of cookbook for the most part.

What it is: A guide to 1830s New England cooking. This book adapts recipes from early 1800s New England and puts them into a format modern readers can follow. Why buy it then since most of the source books are public domain (The American Frugal Housewife, New England Cookery)? Take a look at those books and you’ll see why. Although they make for a fun read, you have to be pretty familiar with the end result of a lot of the recipes to decode the instructions. The old books usually don’t include exact measures or cooking times and often instruct you to do something “in the normal way.”  I learned this the hard way when I discovered that “molasses to taste” in an Indian Pudding meant something like a cup; I’d only used two tablespoons!
Why I love it: This is another sentimental book to me because I interned at Old Sturbridge Village this past summer. If you are ever near Massachusetts go check them out! I’m also a history nerd so a book of historic recipes and food ways is obviously attractive. My favorite feature, however, is that each recipe includes: original instructions from a period source, a modern method “translation”, and a hearth cooking method! Okay, so maybe I don’t have a hearth of my own, but it is pretty fun to read and often could be accomplished on a campfire if you have the right equipment.
What I don’t love: I know I said I love that the recipes are historic but that’s also sometimes a downside. Unless you are feeling adventurous, some of the recipes don’t always sound appealing. Carrot Pie anyone (it’s actually pretty good)? Also, ingredients that were commonplace in the 1830s are a little harder to come by these days. In some cases that just means adding a few things to the spice rack that you don’t often see in modern recipes (inconvenient but do-able) but other times it means that it is really hard to find necessary ingredients like currants.  

No comments:

Post a Comment